Mercurial > hg > truffle
annotate doc/design/graal_compiler.tex @ 2571:ac868ecd3cfc
doc: smaller font, new quad and quadsplit nodes
author | Lukas Stadler <lukas.stadler@jku.at> |
---|---|
date | Tue, 03 May 2011 15:13:19 +0200 |
parents | 7aa67f5f3884 |
children | d1ea2563836d c59db1f02893 |
rev | line source |
---|---|
2517
8c6e31c62fba
added initial version of design docs, fixed .hgignore (regex, . -> \.)
Lukas Stadler <lukas.stadler@jku.at>
parents:
diff
changeset
|
1 \documentclass[twocolumn]{svjour3} |
8c6e31c62fba
added initial version of design docs, fixed .hgignore (regex, . -> \.)
Lukas Stadler <lukas.stadler@jku.at>
parents:
diff
changeset
|
2 \usepackage[pdftex]{graphicx} |
8c6e31c62fba
added initial version of design docs, fixed .hgignore (regex, . -> \.)
Lukas Stadler <lukas.stadler@jku.at>
parents:
diff
changeset
|
3 \usepackage{environ} |
8c6e31c62fba
added initial version of design docs, fixed .hgignore (regex, . -> \.)
Lukas Stadler <lukas.stadler@jku.at>
parents:
diff
changeset
|
4 \usepackage{amsmath} |
8c6e31c62fba
added initial version of design docs, fixed .hgignore (regex, . -> \.)
Lukas Stadler <lukas.stadler@jku.at>
parents:
diff
changeset
|
5 \usepackage{amsfonts} |
8c6e31c62fba
added initial version of design docs, fixed .hgignore (regex, . -> \.)
Lukas Stadler <lukas.stadler@jku.at>
parents:
diff
changeset
|
6 \usepackage[english]{babel} |
8c6e31c62fba
added initial version of design docs, fixed .hgignore (regex, . -> \.)
Lukas Stadler <lukas.stadler@jku.at>
parents:
diff
changeset
|
7 \usepackage[utf8]{inputenc} |
8c6e31c62fba
added initial version of design docs, fixed .hgignore (regex, . -> \.)
Lukas Stadler <lukas.stadler@jku.at>
parents:
diff
changeset
|
8 \usepackage{lmodern} |
8c6e31c62fba
added initial version of design docs, fixed .hgignore (regex, . -> \.)
Lukas Stadler <lukas.stadler@jku.at>
parents:
diff
changeset
|
9 \usepackage[T1]{fontenc} |
8c6e31c62fba
added initial version of design docs, fixed .hgignore (regex, . -> \.)
Lukas Stadler <lukas.stadler@jku.at>
parents:
diff
changeset
|
10 \usepackage{color} |
8c6e31c62fba
added initial version of design docs, fixed .hgignore (regex, . -> \.)
Lukas Stadler <lukas.stadler@jku.at>
parents:
diff
changeset
|
11 |
8c6e31c62fba
added initial version of design docs, fixed .hgignore (regex, . -> \.)
Lukas Stadler <lukas.stadler@jku.at>
parents:
diff
changeset
|
12 \input{graphdrawing} |
8c6e31c62fba
added initial version of design docs, fixed .hgignore (regex, . -> \.)
Lukas Stadler <lukas.stadler@jku.at>
parents:
diff
changeset
|
13 |
8c6e31c62fba
added initial version of design docs, fixed .hgignore (regex, . -> \.)
Lukas Stadler <lukas.stadler@jku.at>
parents:
diff
changeset
|
14 \renewcommand*\descriptionlabel[1]{\hspace\labelsep\normalfont\bf #1} |
8c6e31c62fba
added initial version of design docs, fixed .hgignore (regex, . -> \.)
Lukas Stadler <lukas.stadler@jku.at>
parents:
diff
changeset
|
15 |
8c6e31c62fba
added initial version of design docs, fixed .hgignore (regex, . -> \.)
Lukas Stadler <lukas.stadler@jku.at>
parents:
diff
changeset
|
16 \newcommand{\Sa}{{\Large$^*$}} |
8c6e31c62fba
added initial version of design docs, fixed .hgignore (regex, . -> \.)
Lukas Stadler <lukas.stadler@jku.at>
parents:
diff
changeset
|
17 \newcommand{\Sb}{{\Large$^\dag$}} |
8c6e31c62fba
added initial version of design docs, fixed .hgignore (regex, . -> \.)
Lukas Stadler <lukas.stadler@jku.at>
parents:
diff
changeset
|
18 \newcommand{\Sc}{{\Large$^\S$}} |
8c6e31c62fba
added initial version of design docs, fixed .hgignore (regex, . -> \.)
Lukas Stadler <lukas.stadler@jku.at>
parents:
diff
changeset
|
19 |
2562 | 20 |
21 \newcommand{\mynote}[2]{ | |
22 \textcolor{red}{\fbox{\bfseries\sffamily\scriptsize#1} | |
23 {\small\textsf{\emph{#2}}} | |
24 \fbox{\bfseries\sffamily\scriptsize }}} | |
25 | |
26 \newcommand\TODO[1]{\mynote{TODO}{#1}} | |
27 \newcommand\cw[1]{\mynote{CW}{#1}} | |
28 | |
29 | |
30 | |
2517
8c6e31c62fba
added initial version of design docs, fixed .hgignore (regex, . -> \.)
Lukas Stadler <lukas.stadler@jku.at>
parents:
diff
changeset
|
31 \smartqed % flush right qed marks, e.g. at end of proof |
8c6e31c62fba
added initial version of design docs, fixed .hgignore (regex, . -> \.)
Lukas Stadler <lukas.stadler@jku.at>
parents:
diff
changeset
|
32 |
8c6e31c62fba
added initial version of design docs, fixed .hgignore (regex, . -> \.)
Lukas Stadler <lukas.stadler@jku.at>
parents:
diff
changeset
|
33 \journalname{Graal Compiler Design} |
8c6e31c62fba
added initial version of design docs, fixed .hgignore (regex, . -> \.)
Lukas Stadler <lukas.stadler@jku.at>
parents:
diff
changeset
|
34 \def\makeheadbox{{% |
8c6e31c62fba
added initial version of design docs, fixed .hgignore (regex, . -> \.)
Lukas Stadler <lukas.stadler@jku.at>
parents:
diff
changeset
|
35 \hbox to0pt{\vbox{\baselineskip=10dd\hrule\hbox |
8c6e31c62fba
added initial version of design docs, fixed .hgignore (regex, . -> \.)
Lukas Stadler <lukas.stadler@jku.at>
parents:
diff
changeset
|
36 to\hsize{\vrule\kern3pt\vbox{\kern3pt |
8c6e31c62fba
added initial version of design docs, fixed .hgignore (regex, . -> \.)
Lukas Stadler <lukas.stadler@jku.at>
parents:
diff
changeset
|
37 \hbox{\bfseries The Graal Compiler - Design and Strategy} |
8c6e31c62fba
added initial version of design docs, fixed .hgignore (regex, . -> \.)
Lukas Stadler <lukas.stadler@jku.at>
parents:
diff
changeset
|
38 \kern3pt}\hfil\kern3pt\vrule}\hrule}% |
8c6e31c62fba
added initial version of design docs, fixed .hgignore (regex, . -> \.)
Lukas Stadler <lukas.stadler@jku.at>
parents:
diff
changeset
|
39 \hss}}} |
8c6e31c62fba
added initial version of design docs, fixed .hgignore (regex, . -> \.)
Lukas Stadler <lukas.stadler@jku.at>
parents:
diff
changeset
|
40 |
8c6e31c62fba
added initial version of design docs, fixed .hgignore (regex, . -> \.)
Lukas Stadler <lukas.stadler@jku.at>
parents:
diff
changeset
|
41 \begin{document} |
8c6e31c62fba
added initial version of design docs, fixed .hgignore (regex, . -> \.)
Lukas Stadler <lukas.stadler@jku.at>
parents:
diff
changeset
|
42 |
2561
765dd54244a6
Updated doc. Added Texclipse project.
Thomas Wuerthinger <thomas@wuerthinger.net>
parents:
2517
diff
changeset
|
43 \author{Thomas W\"{u}rthinger \Sa, Lukas Stadler \Sc, Gilles Duboscq \Sa} |
2517
8c6e31c62fba
added initial version of design docs, fixed .hgignore (regex, . -> \.)
Lukas Stadler <lukas.stadler@jku.at>
parents:
diff
changeset
|
44 \institute{\Sa Oracle, \Sc Johannes Kepler University, Linz} |
8c6e31c62fba
added initial version of design docs, fixed .hgignore (regex, . -> \.)
Lukas Stadler <lukas.stadler@jku.at>
parents:
diff
changeset
|
45 |
8c6e31c62fba
added initial version of design docs, fixed .hgignore (regex, . -> \.)
Lukas Stadler <lukas.stadler@jku.at>
parents:
diff
changeset
|
46 \date{Created: \today} |
8c6e31c62fba
added initial version of design docs, fixed .hgignore (regex, . -> \.)
Lukas Stadler <lukas.stadler@jku.at>
parents:
diff
changeset
|
47 |
8c6e31c62fba
added initial version of design docs, fixed .hgignore (regex, . -> \.)
Lukas Stadler <lukas.stadler@jku.at>
parents:
diff
changeset
|
48 \title{The Graal Compiler} |
8c6e31c62fba
added initial version of design docs, fixed .hgignore (regex, . -> \.)
Lukas Stadler <lukas.stadler@jku.at>
parents:
diff
changeset
|
49 \subtitle{Design and Strategy \\ \textcolor{red}{work in progress}} |
8c6e31c62fba
added initial version of design docs, fixed .hgignore (regex, . -> \.)
Lukas Stadler <lukas.stadler@jku.at>
parents:
diff
changeset
|
50 |
8c6e31c62fba
added initial version of design docs, fixed .hgignore (regex, . -> \.)
Lukas Stadler <lukas.stadler@jku.at>
parents:
diff
changeset
|
51 \maketitle |
8c6e31c62fba
added initial version of design docs, fixed .hgignore (regex, . -> \.)
Lukas Stadler <lukas.stadler@jku.at>
parents:
diff
changeset
|
52 |
2561
765dd54244a6
Updated doc. Added Texclipse project.
Thomas Wuerthinger <thomas@wuerthinger.net>
parents:
2517
diff
changeset
|
53 \abstract{ |
765dd54244a6
Updated doc. Added Texclipse project.
Thomas Wuerthinger <thomas@wuerthinger.net>
parents:
2517
diff
changeset
|
54 The Graal compiler aims at improving C1X, the Java port of the HotSpot client compiler, both in terms of modularity and peak performance. |
765dd54244a6
Updated doc. Added Texclipse project.
Thomas Wuerthinger <thomas@wuerthinger.net>
parents:
2517
diff
changeset
|
55 The compiler should work with the Maxine VM and the HotSpot VM. |
765dd54244a6
Updated doc. Added Texclipse project.
Thomas Wuerthinger <thomas@wuerthinger.net>
parents:
2517
diff
changeset
|
56 This document contains information about the proposed design and strategy for developing the Graal compiler.} |
765dd54244a6
Updated doc. Added Texclipse project.
Thomas Wuerthinger <thomas@wuerthinger.net>
parents:
2517
diff
changeset
|
57 |
765dd54244a6
Updated doc. Added Texclipse project.
Thomas Wuerthinger <thomas@wuerthinger.net>
parents:
2517
diff
changeset
|
58 \section{Context} |
765dd54244a6
Updated doc. Added Texclipse project.
Thomas Wuerthinger <thomas@wuerthinger.net>
parents:
2517
diff
changeset
|
59 |
765dd54244a6
Updated doc. Added Texclipse project.
Thomas Wuerthinger <thomas@wuerthinger.net>
parents:
2517
diff
changeset
|
60 In 2009, the Maxine team started with creating C1X, a Java port of the HotSpot client compiler, and integrate it into the Maxine VM. |
765dd54244a6
Updated doc. Added Texclipse project.
Thomas Wuerthinger <thomas@wuerthinger.net>
parents:
2517
diff
changeset
|
61 Part of this effort, was the development of a clear and clean compiler-runtime interface that allows the separation of the compiler and the VM that enables the use of one compiler for multiple VMs. |
765dd54244a6
Updated doc. Added Texclipse project.
Thomas Wuerthinger <thomas@wuerthinger.net>
parents:
2517
diff
changeset
|
62 In June 2010, we started integrating C1X into the HotSpot VM and we called the resulting system Graal~VM. |
765dd54244a6
Updated doc. Added Texclipse project.
Thomas Wuerthinger <thomas@wuerthinger.net>
parents:
2517
diff
changeset
|
63 Currently, the Graal~VM is fully functional and runs benchmarks (SciMark, DaCapo) at a similar speed to the HotSpot client compiler. |
765dd54244a6
Updated doc. Added Texclipse project.
Thomas Wuerthinger <thomas@wuerthinger.net>
parents:
2517
diff
changeset
|
64 |
765dd54244a6
Updated doc. Added Texclipse project.
Thomas Wuerthinger <thomas@wuerthinger.net>
parents:
2517
diff
changeset
|
65 \section{Goals} |
765dd54244a6
Updated doc. Added Texclipse project.
Thomas Wuerthinger <thomas@wuerthinger.net>
parents:
2517
diff
changeset
|
66 The Graal compiler effort aims at rewriting the high-level intermediate representation of C1X with two main goals: |
765dd54244a6
Updated doc. Added Texclipse project.
Thomas Wuerthinger <thomas@wuerthinger.net>
parents:
2517
diff
changeset
|
67 \begin{description} |
765dd54244a6
Updated doc. Added Texclipse project.
Thomas Wuerthinger <thomas@wuerthinger.net>
parents:
2517
diff
changeset
|
68 \item[Modularity:] A modular design of the compiler should simplify the implementation of new languages, new back-ends, and new optimizations. |
765dd54244a6
Updated doc. Added Texclipse project.
Thomas Wuerthinger <thomas@wuerthinger.net>
parents:
2517
diff
changeset
|
69 \item[Peak Performance:] A more powerful intermediate representation should enable the implementation of heavy-weight optimizations that impact the peak performance of the resulting machine code. |
765dd54244a6
Updated doc. Added Texclipse project.
Thomas Wuerthinger <thomas@wuerthinger.net>
parents:
2517
diff
changeset
|
70 \end{description} |
765dd54244a6
Updated doc. Added Texclipse project.
Thomas Wuerthinger <thomas@wuerthinger.net>
parents:
2517
diff
changeset
|
71 |
765dd54244a6
Updated doc. Added Texclipse project.
Thomas Wuerthinger <thomas@wuerthinger.net>
parents:
2517
diff
changeset
|
72 \section{Design} |
765dd54244a6
Updated doc. Added Texclipse project.
Thomas Wuerthinger <thomas@wuerthinger.net>
parents:
2517
diff
changeset
|
73 For the implementation of the Graal compiler, we rely on the following design decisions: |
765dd54244a6
Updated doc. Added Texclipse project.
Thomas Wuerthinger <thomas@wuerthinger.net>
parents:
2517
diff
changeset
|
74 \begin{description} |
765dd54244a6
Updated doc. Added Texclipse project.
Thomas Wuerthinger <thomas@wuerthinger.net>
parents:
2517
diff
changeset
|
75 \item[Graph Representation:] |
2562 | 76 The compiler's intermediate representation is modeled as a graph with nodes that are connected with directed edges. |
2561
765dd54244a6
Updated doc. Added Texclipse project.
Thomas Wuerthinger <thomas@wuerthinger.net>
parents:
2517
diff
changeset
|
77 There is only a single node base class and every node has an associated graph object that does not change during the node's lifetime. |
765dd54244a6
Updated doc. Added Texclipse project.
Thomas Wuerthinger <thomas@wuerthinger.net>
parents:
2517
diff
changeset
|
78 Every node is serializable and has an id that is unique within its graph. |
765dd54244a6
Updated doc. Added Texclipse project.
Thomas Wuerthinger <thomas@wuerthinger.net>
parents:
2517
diff
changeset
|
79 Every edge is classified as either a control flow edge (anti-dependency) or a data flow edge (dependency) and represented as a simple pointer from the source node to the target node. |
2562 | 80 There is no cycle in the graph that contains only control flow edges or only data flow edges. \cw{What does that sentence mean? I can certainly think of a loop that has a control-flow cycle, but no data-flow cycle.} |
2561
765dd54244a6
Updated doc. Added Texclipse project.
Thomas Wuerthinger <thomas@wuerthinger.net>
parents:
2517
diff
changeset
|
81 It is possible to replace a node with another node without traversing the full graph. |
765dd54244a6
Updated doc. Added Texclipse project.
Thomas Wuerthinger <thomas@wuerthinger.net>
parents:
2517
diff
changeset
|
82 \item[Extensibility:] |
765dd54244a6
Updated doc. Added Texclipse project.
Thomas Wuerthinger <thomas@wuerthinger.net>
parents:
2517
diff
changeset
|
83 The compiler is extensible by adding new compiler phases and new node subclasses without modifying the compiler's sources. |
765dd54244a6
Updated doc. Added Texclipse project.
Thomas Wuerthinger <thomas@wuerthinger.net>
parents:
2517
diff
changeset
|
84 A node has an abstract way of expressing its effect and new compiler phases can ask compiler nodes for their properties and capabilities. |
2562 | 85 \cw{Add: We use the ``everything is an extension'' concept. Even standard compiler optimizations are internally modeled as extensions, to show that the extension mechanism exposes all necessary functionality.} |
2561
765dd54244a6
Updated doc. Added Texclipse project.
Thomas Wuerthinger <thomas@wuerthinger.net>
parents:
2517
diff
changeset
|
86 \item[Detailing:] |
765dd54244a6
Updated doc. Added Texclipse project.
Thomas Wuerthinger <thomas@wuerthinger.net>
parents:
2517
diff
changeset
|
87 The compilation starts with a graph that contains nodes that represent the operations of the source language (e.g., one node for an array store to an object array). |
765dd54244a6
Updated doc. Added Texclipse project.
Thomas Wuerthinger <thomas@wuerthinger.net>
parents:
2517
diff
changeset
|
88 During the compilation, the nodes are replaced with more detailed nodes (e.g., the array store node is split into a null check, a bounds check, a store check, and a memory access). |
765dd54244a6
Updated doc. Added Texclipse project.
Thomas Wuerthinger <thomas@wuerthinger.net>
parents:
2517
diff
changeset
|
89 Compiler phases can choose whether they want to work on the earlier versions of the graph (e.g., escape analysis) or on later versions (e.g., null check elimination). |
2562 | 90 \cw{In general, I agree that the lowering should happen without changing the style of IR. However, I don't agree that optimizations such as null check elimination should work on a lower level graph. Isn't it bette to model ``needs null check'' as a capability of high-level instructions? Then the eliminator just sets a property that no null check is necessary. But that is a good discussion point: How much optimization do we want to do by augmenting a high-level IR, and how much do we want to do by rewriting a low-level IR.} |
2561
765dd54244a6
Updated doc. Added Texclipse project.
Thomas Wuerthinger <thomas@wuerthinger.net>
parents:
2517
diff
changeset
|
91 \item[Generality:] |
765dd54244a6
Updated doc. Added Texclipse project.
Thomas Wuerthinger <thomas@wuerthinger.net>
parents:
2517
diff
changeset
|
92 The compiler does not require Java as its input. |
765dd54244a6
Updated doc. Added Texclipse project.
Thomas Wuerthinger <thomas@wuerthinger.net>
parents:
2517
diff
changeset
|
93 This is achieved by having a graph as the starting point of the compilation and not a Java bytecodes array. |
765dd54244a6
Updated doc. Added Texclipse project.
Thomas Wuerthinger <thomas@wuerthinger.net>
parents:
2517
diff
changeset
|
94 Building the graph from the Java bytecodes must happen before giving a method to the compiler. |
765dd54244a6
Updated doc. Added Texclipse project.
Thomas Wuerthinger <thomas@wuerthinger.net>
parents:
2517
diff
changeset
|
95 This enables front-ends for different languages (e.g., Ruby) to provide their own graph. |
765dd54244a6
Updated doc. Added Texclipse project.
Thomas Wuerthinger <thomas@wuerthinger.net>
parents:
2517
diff
changeset
|
96 Also, there is no dependency on a specific back-end, but the output of the compiler is a graph that can then be converted to a different representation in a final compiler phase. |
2562 | 97 \cw{Here we are getting into the nits of terminology. I think the term ``compiler'' should always refer to the whole system that goes from bytecodes to machine code. Yes, there will be additional parsers for different bytecode formats. But still, the compiler doesn't have graphs as input and outputs, but still bytecodes and machine code, respectively.} |
2561
765dd54244a6
Updated doc. Added Texclipse project.
Thomas Wuerthinger <thomas@wuerthinger.net>
parents:
2517
diff
changeset
|
98 \end{description} |
765dd54244a6
Updated doc. Added Texclipse project.
Thomas Wuerthinger <thomas@wuerthinger.net>
parents:
2517
diff
changeset
|
99 |
765dd54244a6
Updated doc. Added Texclipse project.
Thomas Wuerthinger <thomas@wuerthinger.net>
parents:
2517
diff
changeset
|
100 \section{Milestones} |
765dd54244a6
Updated doc. Added Texclipse project.
Thomas Wuerthinger <thomas@wuerthinger.net>
parents:
2517
diff
changeset
|
101 The Graal compiler is developed starting from the current C1X source code base. |
765dd54244a6
Updated doc. Added Texclipse project.
Thomas Wuerthinger <thomas@wuerthinger.net>
parents:
2517
diff
changeset
|
102 This helps us testing the compiler at every intermediate development step on a variety of Java benchmarks. |
765dd54244a6
Updated doc. Added Texclipse project.
Thomas Wuerthinger <thomas@wuerthinger.net>
parents:
2517
diff
changeset
|
103 We define the following development milestones and when they are considered achieved: |
765dd54244a6
Updated doc. Added Texclipse project.
Thomas Wuerthinger <thomas@wuerthinger.net>
parents:
2517
diff
changeset
|
104 \begin{description} |
765dd54244a6
Updated doc. Added Texclipse project.
Thomas Wuerthinger <thomas@wuerthinger.net>
parents:
2517
diff
changeset
|
105 \item[M1:] We have a fully working Graal VM version with a stripped down C1X compiler that does not perform any optimizations. |
765dd54244a6
Updated doc. Added Texclipse project.
Thomas Wuerthinger <thomas@wuerthinger.net>
parents:
2517
diff
changeset
|
106 \item[M2:] We modified the high-level intermediate representation to be based on the Graal compiler graph data structure. |
765dd54244a6
Updated doc. Added Texclipse project.
Thomas Wuerthinger <thomas@wuerthinger.net>
parents:
2517
diff
changeset
|
107 \item[M3:] We have reimplemented and reenabled compiler optimizations in the Graal compiler that previously existed in C1X. |
765dd54244a6
Updated doc. Added Texclipse project.
Thomas Wuerthinger <thomas@wuerthinger.net>
parents:
2517
diff
changeset
|
108 \item[M4:] We have reintegrated the new Graal compiler into the Maxine VM and can use it as a Maxine VM bootstrapping compiler. |
765dd54244a6
Updated doc. Added Texclipse project.
Thomas Wuerthinger <thomas@wuerthinger.net>
parents:
2517
diff
changeset
|
109 \end{description} |
765dd54244a6
Updated doc. Added Texclipse project.
Thomas Wuerthinger <thomas@wuerthinger.net>
parents:
2517
diff
changeset
|
110 |
765dd54244a6
Updated doc. Added Texclipse project.
Thomas Wuerthinger <thomas@wuerthinger.net>
parents:
2517
diff
changeset
|
111 After those four milestones, we see three different possible further development directions that can be followed in parallel: |
765dd54244a6
Updated doc. Added Texclipse project.
Thomas Wuerthinger <thomas@wuerthinger.net>
parents:
2517
diff
changeset
|
112 \begin{itemize} |
765dd54244a6
Updated doc. Added Texclipse project.
Thomas Wuerthinger <thomas@wuerthinger.net>
parents:
2517
diff
changeset
|
113 \item Removal of the XIR template mechanism and replacement with a snippet mechanism that works with the Graal compiler graph. |
765dd54244a6
Updated doc. Added Texclipse project.
Thomas Wuerthinger <thomas@wuerthinger.net>
parents:
2517
diff
changeset
|
114 \item Improvements for Graal peak performance (loop optimizations, escape analysis, bounds check elimination, processing additional interpreter runtime feedback). |
2562 | 115 \item Implementation of a prototype front-end for different languages, e.g., JavaScript. |
2561
765dd54244a6
Updated doc. Added Texclipse project.
Thomas Wuerthinger <thomas@wuerthinger.net>
parents:
2517
diff
changeset
|
116 \end{itemize} |
765dd54244a6
Updated doc. Added Texclipse project.
Thomas Wuerthinger <thomas@wuerthinger.net>
parents:
2517
diff
changeset
|
117 |
765dd54244a6
Updated doc. Added Texclipse project.
Thomas Wuerthinger <thomas@wuerthinger.net>
parents:
2517
diff
changeset
|
118 \section{Implementation} |
765dd54244a6
Updated doc. Added Texclipse project.
Thomas Wuerthinger <thomas@wuerthinger.net>
parents:
2517
diff
changeset
|
119 |
765dd54244a6
Updated doc. Added Texclipse project.
Thomas Wuerthinger <thomas@wuerthinger.net>
parents:
2517
diff
changeset
|
120 |
765dd54244a6
Updated doc. Added Texclipse project.
Thomas Wuerthinger <thomas@wuerthinger.net>
parents:
2517
diff
changeset
|
121 \subsection{Project Source Structure} |
765dd54244a6
Updated doc. Added Texclipse project.
Thomas Wuerthinger <thomas@wuerthinger.net>
parents:
2517
diff
changeset
|
122 In order to have clear interfaces between the different parts of the compiler, the code will be divided into the following source code projects: |
2562 | 123 \cw{Use new naming scheme com.oracle.graal...} |
2561
765dd54244a6
Updated doc. Added Texclipse project.
Thomas Wuerthinger <thomas@wuerthinger.net>
parents:
2517
diff
changeset
|
124 \begin{description} |
765dd54244a6
Updated doc. Added Texclipse project.
Thomas Wuerthinger <thomas@wuerthinger.net>
parents:
2517
diff
changeset
|
125 \item[Graph] contains the abstract node implementation, the graph implementation and all the associated tools and auxiliary classes. |
2562 | 126 \item[Nodes] contains the node implementations, ranging from high-level to machine-level nodes. \cw{Can't we just stay with the name ``instruction'', which everyone understands, instead of ``Node''? I strongly vote for that.} |
127 \item[GraphBuilder] contains helpers for building graphs from Java bytecodes and other source representations. | |
2561
765dd54244a6
Updated doc. Added Texclipse project.
Thomas Wuerthinger <thomas@wuerthinger.net>
parents:
2517
diff
changeset
|
128 \item[Assembler] contains the assembler classes that are used to generate the compiled code of methods and stubs. |
765dd54244a6
Updated doc. Added Texclipse project.
Thomas Wuerthinger <thomas@wuerthinger.net>
parents:
2517
diff
changeset
|
129 \item[Optimizations] contains all the optimizations, along with different optimization plans. |
765dd54244a6
Updated doc. Added Texclipse project.
Thomas Wuerthinger <thomas@wuerthinger.net>
parents:
2517
diff
changeset
|
130 \item[GraalCompiler] contains the compiler, including: |
765dd54244a6
Updated doc. Added Texclipse project.
Thomas Wuerthinger <thomas@wuerthinger.net>
parents:
2517
diff
changeset
|
131 \begin{itemize} |
765dd54244a6
Updated doc. Added Texclipse project.
Thomas Wuerthinger <thomas@wuerthinger.net>
parents:
2517
diff
changeset
|
132 \item Handling of compilation phases. |
765dd54244a6
Updated doc. Added Texclipse project.
Thomas Wuerthinger <thomas@wuerthinger.net>
parents:
2517
diff
changeset
|
133 \item Compilation-related data structures. |
765dd54244a6
Updated doc. Added Texclipse project.
Thomas Wuerthinger <thomas@wuerthinger.net>
parents:
2517
diff
changeset
|
134 \item Implementation of the \emph{compiler interface} (CI). |
765dd54244a6
Updated doc. Added Texclipse project.
Thomas Wuerthinger <thomas@wuerthinger.net>
parents:
2517
diff
changeset
|
135 \item Register allocation. |
765dd54244a6
Updated doc. Added Texclipse project.
Thomas Wuerthinger <thomas@wuerthinger.net>
parents:
2517
diff
changeset
|
136 \item Machine code creation, including debug info. |
765dd54244a6
Updated doc. Added Texclipse project.
Thomas Wuerthinger <thomas@wuerthinger.net>
parents:
2517
diff
changeset
|
137 \item Debug output and compilation observation. |
765dd54244a6
Updated doc. Added Texclipse project.
Thomas Wuerthinger <thomas@wuerthinger.net>
parents:
2517
diff
changeset
|
138 \item Compiler options management. |
765dd54244a6
Updated doc. Added Texclipse project.
Thomas Wuerthinger <thomas@wuerthinger.net>
parents:
2517
diff
changeset
|
139 \end{itemize} |
2562 | 140 \cw{So you want to keep the backend as part of the ``main compiler'' at first. Seems OK for me.} |
2561
765dd54244a6
Updated doc. Added Texclipse project.
Thomas Wuerthinger <thomas@wuerthinger.net>
parents:
2517
diff
changeset
|
141 \end{description} |
765dd54244a6
Updated doc. Added Texclipse project.
Thomas Wuerthinger <thomas@wuerthinger.net>
parents:
2517
diff
changeset
|
142 |
765dd54244a6
Updated doc. Added Texclipse project.
Thomas Wuerthinger <thomas@wuerthinger.net>
parents:
2517
diff
changeset
|
143 \subsection{Initial Steps} |
765dd54244a6
Updated doc. Added Texclipse project.
Thomas Wuerthinger <thomas@wuerthinger.net>
parents:
2517
diff
changeset
|
144 \begin{itemize} |
765dd54244a6
Updated doc. Added Texclipse project.
Thomas Wuerthinger <thomas@wuerthinger.net>
parents:
2517
diff
changeset
|
145 \item Restructuring of the project to include the compiler and the modified HotSpot code within one repository. The CRI project will remain in the Maxine repository, because it will remain mostly unchanged. |
765dd54244a6
Updated doc. Added Texclipse project.
Thomas Wuerthinger <thomas@wuerthinger.net>
parents:
2517
diff
changeset
|
146 \item Stripping optimizations from the existing compiler, they will be reimplemented later on using the new infrastructure. |
765dd54244a6
Updated doc. Added Texclipse project.
Thomas Wuerthinger <thomas@wuerthinger.net>
parents:
2517
diff
changeset
|
147 \item Creating Node and Graph classes, along with the necessary auxiliary classes. |
765dd54244a6
Updated doc. Added Texclipse project.
Thomas Wuerthinger <thomas@wuerthinger.net>
parents:
2517
diff
changeset
|
148 \item Writing documentation on the design of the compiler. |
765dd54244a6
Updated doc. Added Texclipse project.
Thomas Wuerthinger <thomas@wuerthinger.net>
parents:
2517
diff
changeset
|
149 \item Use the Node class as the superclass of the existing Value class. |
765dd54244a6
Updated doc. Added Texclipse project.
Thomas Wuerthinger <thomas@wuerthinger.net>
parents:
2517
diff
changeset
|
150 \item Identify (and later: remove) extended bytecodes. |
765dd54244a6
Updated doc. Added Texclipse project.
Thomas Wuerthinger <thomas@wuerthinger.net>
parents:
2517
diff
changeset
|
151 \item Implement the new frame state concept. |
2562 | 152 \item Remove LIR - in the long run there should only be one IR, which will be continually lowered until only nodes that can be translated into machine code remain. \cw{That cannot be an initial step, because you have nothing yet that could replace the LIR.} |
2561
765dd54244a6
Updated doc. Added Texclipse project.
Thomas Wuerthinger <thomas@wuerthinger.net>
parents:
2517
diff
changeset
|
153 \end{itemize} |
765dd54244a6
Updated doc. Added Texclipse project.
Thomas Wuerthinger <thomas@wuerthinger.net>
parents:
2517
diff
changeset
|
154 |
765dd54244a6
Updated doc. Added Texclipse project.
Thomas Wuerthinger <thomas@wuerthinger.net>
parents:
2517
diff
changeset
|
155 \subsection{Nodes and Graphs} |
765dd54244a6
Updated doc. Added Texclipse project.
Thomas Wuerthinger <thomas@wuerthinger.net>
parents:
2517
diff
changeset
|
156 The most important aspect of a compiler is the data structure that holds information about an executable piece of code, called \emph{intermediate representation}~(IR). |
2562 | 157 The IR used in the Graal Compiler (simply referred to as \emph{the compiler} in the rest of this document) was designed in such a way as to allow for extensive optimizations, easy traversal, compact storage and efficient processing. |
2561
765dd54244a6
Updated doc. Added Texclipse project.
Thomas Wuerthinger <thomas@wuerthinger.net>
parents:
2517
diff
changeset
|
158 |
765dd54244a6
Updated doc. Added Texclipse project.
Thomas Wuerthinger <thomas@wuerthinger.net>
parents:
2517
diff
changeset
|
159 \subsubsection{The Node Data Structure} |
765dd54244a6
Updated doc. Added Texclipse project.
Thomas Wuerthinger <thomas@wuerthinger.net>
parents:
2517
diff
changeset
|
160 \begin{itemize} |
765dd54244a6
Updated doc. Added Texclipse project.
Thomas Wuerthinger <thomas@wuerthinger.net>
parents:
2517
diff
changeset
|
161 \item Each node is always associated with a graph. |
2562 | 162 \item Each node has an immutable id which is unique within its associated graph. \cw{The server compiler supports ``renumbering'' of nodes to make the ids dense again after large graph manipulations that deleted many nodes.} |
2561
765dd54244a6
Updated doc. Added Texclipse project.
Thomas Wuerthinger <thomas@wuerthinger.net>
parents:
2517
diff
changeset
|
163 \item Nodes represent either operations on values or control flow operations. |
765dd54244a6
Updated doc. Added Texclipse project.
Thomas Wuerthinger <thomas@wuerthinger.net>
parents:
2517
diff
changeset
|
164 \item Nodes can have a data dependency, which means that one node requires the result of some other node as its input. The fact that the result of the first node needs to be computed before the second node can be executed introduces a partial order to the set of nodes. |
765dd54244a6
Updated doc. Added Texclipse project.
Thomas Wuerthinger <thomas@wuerthinger.net>
parents:
2517
diff
changeset
|
165 \item Nodes can have a control flow dependency, which means that the execution of one node depends on some other node. This includes conditional execution, memory access serialization and other reasons, and again introduces a partial order to the set of nodes. |
765dd54244a6
Updated doc. Added Texclipse project.
Thomas Wuerthinger <thomas@wuerthinger.net>
parents:
2517
diff
changeset
|
166 \item Nodes can only have data and control dependencies to nodes which belong to the same graph. |
2562 | 167 \item Control dependencies and data dependencies each represent a \emph{directed acyclic graph} (DAG) on the same set of nodes. This means that data dependencies always point upwards, and control dependencies always point downwards. Situations that are normally incur cycles (like loops) are represented by special nodes (like LoopEnd). |
168 \cw{I don't like that item. Cycles are a normal thing for control flow and for phi functions. I would phrase it as something like that: Nodes can only have data and control dependencies to nodes that are dominators. The only exception of that are control loop headers and phi functions} | |
169 \item Ordering between nodes is specified only to the extent which is required to correctly express the semantics of a given program. Some compilers (notably the HotSpot client compiler \cw{Wrong: the client compiler only has a fixed order of pinned instructions, most instructions are not pinned and can be moved around freely}) always maintain a complete order for all nodes (called \emph{scheduling}), which impedes advanced optimizations. For algorithms that require a fixed ordering of nodes, a temporary schedule can always be generated. | |
2561
765dd54244a6
Updated doc. Added Texclipse project.
Thomas Wuerthinger <thomas@wuerthinger.net>
parents:
2517
diff
changeset
|
170 \item Both data and control dependencies can be traversed in both directions, so that each node can be traversed in four directions: |
765dd54244a6
Updated doc. Added Texclipse project.
Thomas Wuerthinger <thomas@wuerthinger.net>
parents:
2517
diff
changeset
|
171 \begin{itemize} |
765dd54244a6
Updated doc. Added Texclipse project.
Thomas Wuerthinger <thomas@wuerthinger.net>
parents:
2517
diff
changeset
|
172 \item \emph{inputs} are all nodes that this node has data dependencies on. |
765dd54244a6
Updated doc. Added Texclipse project.
Thomas Wuerthinger <thomas@wuerthinger.net>
parents:
2517
diff
changeset
|
173 \item \emph{usages} are all nodes that have data dependencies on this node, this is regarded as the inverse of inputs. |
765dd54244a6
Updated doc. Added Texclipse project.
Thomas Wuerthinger <thomas@wuerthinger.net>
parents:
2517
diff
changeset
|
174 \item \emph{successors} are all nodes that have a control dependency on this node. |
765dd54244a6
Updated doc. Added Texclipse project.
Thomas Wuerthinger <thomas@wuerthinger.net>
parents:
2517
diff
changeset
|
175 \item \emph{predecessors} are all nodes that this node has control dependencies on, this is regarded as the inverse of successors. |
765dd54244a6
Updated doc. Added Texclipse project.
Thomas Wuerthinger <thomas@wuerthinger.net>
parents:
2517
diff
changeset
|
176 \end{itemize} |
765dd54244a6
Updated doc. Added Texclipse project.
Thomas Wuerthinger <thomas@wuerthinger.net>
parents:
2517
diff
changeset
|
177 \item Only inputs and successors can be changed, and changes to them will update the usages and predecessors. |
765dd54244a6
Updated doc. Added Texclipse project.
Thomas Wuerthinger <thomas@wuerthinger.net>
parents:
2517
diff
changeset
|
178 \item The Node class needs to provide facilities for subclasses to perform actions upon cloning, dependency changes, etc. |
2562 | 179 \item Nodes cannot be reassigned to another graph, they are cloned instead \cw{Why should there be the need for more than one graph when compiling a method?} |
2561
765dd54244a6
Updated doc. Added Texclipse project.
Thomas Wuerthinger <thomas@wuerthinger.net>
parents:
2517
diff
changeset
|
180 \end{itemize} |
765dd54244a6
Updated doc. Added Texclipse project.
Thomas Wuerthinger <thomas@wuerthinger.net>
parents:
2517
diff
changeset
|
181 |
765dd54244a6
Updated doc. Added Texclipse project.
Thomas Wuerthinger <thomas@wuerthinger.net>
parents:
2517
diff
changeset
|
182 \subsubsection{The Graph Data Structure} |
765dd54244a6
Updated doc. Added Texclipse project.
Thomas Wuerthinger <thomas@wuerthinger.net>
parents:
2517
diff
changeset
|
183 \begin{itemize} |
765dd54244a6
Updated doc. Added Texclipse project.
Thomas Wuerthinger <thomas@wuerthinger.net>
parents:
2517
diff
changeset
|
184 \item A graph deals out ids for new nodes and can be queried for the node corresponding to a given id. |
765dd54244a6
Updated doc. Added Texclipse project.
Thomas Wuerthinger <thomas@wuerthinger.net>
parents:
2517
diff
changeset
|
185 \item Graphs can manage side data structures, which will be automatically invalidated and lazily recomputed whenever the graph changes. Examples for side data structures are dominator trees and temporary schedules. These side data structures will usually be understood by more than one optimization. |
765dd54244a6
Updated doc. Added Texclipse project.
Thomas Wuerthinger <thomas@wuerthinger.net>
parents:
2517
diff
changeset
|
186 \item Graphs are |
765dd54244a6
Updated doc. Added Texclipse project.
Thomas Wuerthinger <thomas@wuerthinger.net>
parents:
2517
diff
changeset
|
187 \end{itemize} |
765dd54244a6
Updated doc. Added Texclipse project.
Thomas Wuerthinger <thomas@wuerthinger.net>
parents:
2517
diff
changeset
|
188 |
765dd54244a6
Updated doc. Added Texclipse project.
Thomas Wuerthinger <thomas@wuerthinger.net>
parents:
2517
diff
changeset
|
189 \subsection{Frame States} |
765dd54244a6
Updated doc. Added Texclipse project.
Thomas Wuerthinger <thomas@wuerthinger.net>
parents:
2517
diff
changeset
|
190 Frame states capture the state of the program, in terms of the source representation (e.g., Java state: local variables, expressions, ...). |
2562 | 191 Whenever a safepoint is reached or \cwi{why is that an ``or'', both is basically the same} a deoptimization is needed a valid frame state needs to be available. |
2561
765dd54244a6
Updated doc. Added Texclipse project.
Thomas Wuerthinger <thomas@wuerthinger.net>
parents:
2517
diff
changeset
|
192 A frame state is valid as long as the program performs only actions that can safely be reexecuted (e.g., operations on local variables, etc.). |
2562 | 193 Thus, frame states need only be generated for bytecodes that cannot be reexecuted: putfield, astore, invoke, monitorenter/exit, ... |
2561
765dd54244a6
Updated doc. Added Texclipse project.
Thomas Wuerthinger <thomas@wuerthinger.net>
parents:
2517
diff
changeset
|
194 |
2562 | 195 Within the node graph a frame state is represented as a node that is fixed between the node that caused it to be generated (data dependency) and the node that invalidates it (control dependency). |
2561
765dd54244a6
Updated doc. Added Texclipse project.
Thomas Wuerthinger <thomas@wuerthinger.net>
parents:
2517
diff
changeset
|
196 |
765dd54244a6
Updated doc. Added Texclipse project.
Thomas Wuerthinger <thomas@wuerthinger.net>
parents:
2517
diff
changeset
|
197 Deopmization nodes are not fixed to a certain frame state node, they can move around freely and will always use the correct frame state. |
2562 | 198 At some point during the compilation, deoptimization nodes need to be fixed, which means that appropriate data and control dependencies will be inserted so that it can not move outside the scope of the associated frame state. |
2561
765dd54244a6
Updated doc. Added Texclipse project.
Thomas Wuerthinger <thomas@wuerthinger.net>
parents:
2517
diff
changeset
|
199 This will generate deoptimization-free zones that can be targeted by the most aggressive optimizations. |
765dd54244a6
Updated doc. Added Texclipse project.
Thomas Wuerthinger <thomas@wuerthinger.net>
parents:
2517
diff
changeset
|
200 |
765dd54244a6
Updated doc. Added Texclipse project.
Thomas Wuerthinger <thomas@wuerthinger.net>
parents:
2517
diff
changeset
|
201 Frame states should be represented using a delta-encoding. |
765dd54244a6
Updated doc. Added Texclipse project.
Thomas Wuerthinger <thomas@wuerthinger.net>
parents:
2517
diff
changeset
|
202 This will make them significantly smaller and will make inlining, etc. much easier. |
765dd54244a6
Updated doc. Added Texclipse project.
Thomas Wuerthinger <thomas@wuerthinger.net>
parents:
2517
diff
changeset
|
203 In later compilation phases unnecessary frame states might be removed, using a mark-and-merge algorithm. |
765dd54244a6
Updated doc. Added Texclipse project.
Thomas Wuerthinger <thomas@wuerthinger.net>
parents:
2517
diff
changeset
|
204 |
765dd54244a6
Updated doc. Added Texclipse project.
Thomas Wuerthinger <thomas@wuerthinger.net>
parents:
2517
diff
changeset
|
205 |
765dd54244a6
Updated doc. Added Texclipse project.
Thomas Wuerthinger <thomas@wuerthinger.net>
parents:
2517
diff
changeset
|
206 |
765dd54244a6
Updated doc. Added Texclipse project.
Thomas Wuerthinger <thomas@wuerthinger.net>
parents:
2517
diff
changeset
|
207 \subsection{Graph Building} |
765dd54244a6
Updated doc. Added Texclipse project.
Thomas Wuerthinger <thomas@wuerthinger.net>
parents:
2517
diff
changeset
|
208 \begin{itemize} |
765dd54244a6
Updated doc. Added Texclipse project.
Thomas Wuerthinger <thomas@wuerthinger.net>
parents:
2517
diff
changeset
|
209 \item The graph built by the initial parser (called \emph{GraphBuilder}) should be as close to the source representation (bytecode, ...) as possible. |
2562 | 210 \item All nodes should be able to immediately lower themselves to a machine-level representation. \cw{What is that? You mean every node has x86 specific code that spits out machine code? Hope you are joking...} This allows for easier compiler development, and also leads to a compiler that is very flexible in the amount of optimizations it performs (e.g. recompilation of methods with more aggressive optimizations). |
2561
765dd54244a6
Updated doc. Added Texclipse project.
Thomas Wuerthinger <thomas@wuerthinger.net>
parents:
2517
diff
changeset
|
211 \item |
765dd54244a6
Updated doc. Added Texclipse project.
Thomas Wuerthinger <thomas@wuerthinger.net>
parents:
2517
diff
changeset
|
212 \end{itemize} |
765dd54244a6
Updated doc. Added Texclipse project.
Thomas Wuerthinger <thomas@wuerthinger.net>
parents:
2517
diff
changeset
|
213 |
765dd54244a6
Updated doc. Added Texclipse project.
Thomas Wuerthinger <thomas@wuerthinger.net>
parents:
2517
diff
changeset
|
214 \subsection{Graphical Representation} |
765dd54244a6
Updated doc. Added Texclipse project.
Thomas Wuerthinger <thomas@wuerthinger.net>
parents:
2517
diff
changeset
|
215 The graphs in this document use the following node layout: |
765dd54244a6
Updated doc. Added Texclipse project.
Thomas Wuerthinger <thomas@wuerthinger.net>
parents:
2517
diff
changeset
|
216 |
765dd54244a6
Updated doc. Added Texclipse project.
Thomas Wuerthinger <thomas@wuerthinger.net>
parents:
2517
diff
changeset
|
217 \begin{digraphenv}{scale=0.5}{layout01} |
765dd54244a6
Updated doc. Added Texclipse project.
Thomas Wuerthinger <thomas@wuerthinger.net>
parents:
2517
diff
changeset
|
218 \node{node1}{nop} |
765dd54244a6
Updated doc. Added Texclipse project.
Thomas Wuerthinger <thomas@wuerthinger.net>
parents:
2517
diff
changeset
|
219 \nodebi{node2}{+} |
765dd54244a6
Updated doc. Added Texclipse project.
Thomas Wuerthinger <thomas@wuerthinger.net>
parents:
2517
diff
changeset
|
220 \nodetri{node3}{phi} |
765dd54244a6
Updated doc. Added Texclipse project.
Thomas Wuerthinger <thomas@wuerthinger.net>
parents:
2517
diff
changeset
|
221 \nodesplit{node4}{if} |
765dd54244a6
Updated doc. Added Texclipse project.
Thomas Wuerthinger <thomas@wuerthinger.net>
parents:
2517
diff
changeset
|
222 \end{digraphenv} |
765dd54244a6
Updated doc. Added Texclipse project.
Thomas Wuerthinger <thomas@wuerthinger.net>
parents:
2517
diff
changeset
|
223 |
2562 | 224 \cw{That doesn't compile with my latex. What do I have to do to get it working?} |
225 | |
2561
765dd54244a6
Updated doc. Added Texclipse project.
Thomas Wuerthinger <thomas@wuerthinger.net>
parents:
2517
diff
changeset
|
226 Red arrows always represents control dependencies, while black arrows represent data dependencies: |
765dd54244a6
Updated doc. Added Texclipse project.
Thomas Wuerthinger <thomas@wuerthinger.net>
parents:
2517
diff
changeset
|
227 |
765dd54244a6
Updated doc. Added Texclipse project.
Thomas Wuerthinger <thomas@wuerthinger.net>
parents:
2517
diff
changeset
|
228 \begin{digraphenv}{scale=0.5}{layout1} |
765dd54244a6
Updated doc. Added Texclipse project.
Thomas Wuerthinger <thomas@wuerthinger.net>
parents:
2517
diff
changeset
|
229 \node{a}{a} |
765dd54244a6
Updated doc. Added Texclipse project.
Thomas Wuerthinger <thomas@wuerthinger.net>
parents:
2517
diff
changeset
|
230 \node{b}{b} |
765dd54244a6
Updated doc. Added Texclipse project.
Thomas Wuerthinger <thomas@wuerthinger.net>
parents:
2517
diff
changeset
|
231 \nodesplit{if}{if} |
765dd54244a6
Updated doc. Added Texclipse project.
Thomas Wuerthinger <thomas@wuerthinger.net>
parents:
2517
diff
changeset
|
232 \node{nop}{nop} |
765dd54244a6
Updated doc. Added Texclipse project.
Thomas Wuerthinger <thomas@wuerthinger.net>
parents:
2517
diff
changeset
|
233 \nodebi{add}{+} |
765dd54244a6
Updated doc. Added Texclipse project.
Thomas Wuerthinger <thomas@wuerthinger.net>
parents:
2517
diff
changeset
|
234 \controllabel{if:succ1}{nop} |
765dd54244a6
Updated doc. Added Texclipse project.
Thomas Wuerthinger <thomas@wuerthinger.net>
parents:
2517
diff
changeset
|
235 \controllabel{if:succ2}{add} |
765dd54244a6
Updated doc. Added Texclipse project.
Thomas Wuerthinger <thomas@wuerthinger.net>
parents:
2517
diff
changeset
|
236 \datalabel{add:in1}{a} |
765dd54244a6
Updated doc. Added Texclipse project.
Thomas Wuerthinger <thomas@wuerthinger.net>
parents:
2517
diff
changeset
|
237 \datalabel{add:in2}{b} |
765dd54244a6
Updated doc. Added Texclipse project.
Thomas Wuerthinger <thomas@wuerthinger.net>
parents:
2517
diff
changeset
|
238 \end{digraphenv} |
765dd54244a6
Updated doc. Added Texclipse project.
Thomas Wuerthinger <thomas@wuerthinger.net>
parents:
2517
diff
changeset
|
239 |
765dd54244a6
Updated doc. Added Texclipse project.
Thomas Wuerthinger <thomas@wuerthinger.net>
parents:
2517
diff
changeset
|
240 |
2517
8c6e31c62fba
added initial version of design docs, fixed .hgignore (regex, . -> \.)
Lukas Stadler <lukas.stadler@jku.at>
parents:
diff
changeset
|
241 |
8c6e31c62fba
added initial version of design docs, fixed .hgignore (regex, . -> \.)
Lukas Stadler <lukas.stadler@jku.at>
parents:
diff
changeset
|
242 \end{document} |